Want to read more? Subscribe Now or Sign In
Hide ( X )
  • THE CRIME REPORT - Your Complete Criminal Justice Resource

  • Investigative News Network
  • Welcome to the Crime Report. Today is

Viewpoints

A Handful of States Lead the Way on Juvenile Crime Prevention

December 4, 2012 06:38:27 am

By Ted Gest

States are "surprisingly slow" in adopting proven methods to deal with violent or delinquent youth and their families, a national juvenile justice conference was told today.

Failure to use the programs has been shown to result in higher crime rates and higher costs---placing youths in facilities or programs that are unproved or may cause youths' behavior to worsen, said Peter Greenwood of the organization Advancing Evidence-Based Practice.

Greenwood spoke at the Models for Change annual conference in Washington, D.C.

Models for Change, started by the MacArthur Foundation in 2004, has invested more than $110 million in 16 states and 35 localities to support juvenile justice reforms.

Many of the efforts have centered in four states: Pennsylvania, Illinois, Louisiana, and Washington.

Greenwood released a survey of states' use of the three most well regarded programs for family therapy that aim at reducing future delinquency. The model programs are called functional family therapy, multi-systemic therapy, and multidimensional treatment foster care.

They involve sending teams of therapists to meet with youth and family members in their homes over a 4-to-9-month period, costing bertween $2,500 and $10,000 per case.

All three programs, which together have been used at more than 700 sites, have been proved to reduce recividism substantially.

The five states that have led by far in the use of these methods are Connecticut, Hawaii, Louisiana, Maine, and New Mexico, which overall make them available five times more than do other states.

Four of the five states started exploring these evidence-based practices in the late 1990s. Louisiana did not adopt them until 2006.

Greenwood and his co-authors, Brandon Welsh and Michael Rocque of Northeastern University, said the five leading states had turned "crisis into opportunity."

Three states were sued by the U.S. Justice Department over substandard conditions in juvenile institutions. In the two other states, "there was a growing political consensus that  many youth being sent to placement did not belong there," he said.

 In all five places, key stakeholders were assembled to take charge of reforms.

The researchers said a main aim of using evidence-based practices was to reduce "excessive use of institutional placements for juvenile offenders."

They took a look at what has happened in the five states. Connecticut has seen a marked decline in juvenile placements compared to the national average. Maine and Hawaii already were below the national average, and their rate has been stable.

Louisiana, which started the process late, had been above the national placement average but has declined to the national rate.

Only in New Mexico have placements increased in recent years, but the 2010 total is well below that reported in 2001.

"Given the obvious and well documented benefits of evidence-based family therapy programs" in the five states, the study's authors said, other states should adopt similar changes to improve the cost-effectiveness of their crime prevention efforts.

Editor's Note: the study is due to be posted later this week at http://advancingebp.org

Ted Gest is president of Criminal Justice Matters and Washington, DC-based contributing editor of The Crime Report. He welcomes comments from readers.

Email this post »

« Article List
No Comments yet

TCR at a Glance

Crime and Prison Population Fall in N.C.

new & notable November 21, 2014

A series of justice reinvestment reforms in North Carolina have created a more efficient system, according to a report by the non-profit ...

Does 'Right-to-Carry' Lead to More Crime?

new & notable November 20, 2014

Laws that allow concealed weapons in public are associated with higher rates of aggravated assault, rape, robbery and murder, according t...

BJS: Crimes Against the Elderly on the Rise

new & notable November 14, 2014

Violent victimizations of Americans 65 or older increased 27 percent from 2003 to 2013, according to a new study by the federal Bureau of...