Want to read more? Subscribe Now or Sign In
Hide ( X )
  • THE CRIME REPORT - Your Complete Criminal Justice Resource

  • Investigative News Network
  • Welcome to the Crime Report. Today is

Inside Criminal Justice

new & notable

Identifying Prosecutors Who Overcharge

March 29, 2013 07:46:42 am

Photo by walknboston, via Flickr

Discussions of prosecutorial overcharging often lump several difference practices into one, according to Kyle Graham of the Santa Clara University School of Law, whose recent essay in the Ohio State Journal of Criminal Law classifies and proposes metrics for overcharging.

The essay notes three types of overcharging: the filing of criminal counts without adequate proof, threatening punishment more severe than the crime befits, and the deliberate use of excessive allegations to induce a plea bargain.

To identify individual district attorney’s offices that rely on overcharging, Graham mined charge-specific data compiled by the Administrative Office of the United States Courts (AOUSC).

One metric he suggested to identify potentially chronic overchargers, was to track the instances in which the “gun enhancement” charge 18 U.S.C. § 924(c) — often used as a bargaining chip, because it carries a five year mandatory minimum sentence — was dismissed. The charge was dismissed more than 70 percent of the time in the Eastern District of Arkansas and the Southern District of Georgia.

Read an abstract and download the essay here.

« Article List
No Comments yet

TCR at a Glance

Caviar’s Last Stand

special report August 1, 2014

How the international caviar underground ended up in the Ozarks

Caging Kids ‘Like Animals’

July 29, 2014

Civil rights groups ask DOJ to investigate San Diego County youth facilities after probe of pepper spray abuses

Merging Family and Drug Courts

new & notable July 25, 2014

London's court for parents who abuse drugs and alcohol uses specially-trained judges and multi-disciplinary teams, according to a report ...

Five Things About Deterrence

new & notable July 24, 2014

A National Institute of Justice flyer argues that the certainty of punishment, rather than severity, deters crime