• THE CRIME REPORT - Your Complete Criminal Justice Resource

  • Investigative News Network
  • Welcome to the Crime Report. Today is

Crime and Justice News

FBI Lab Trainers Passed Erroneous Techniques to State, Local Examiners

December 24, 2012 10:47:23 am

Thousands of criminal cases at the state and local level may have relied on exaggerated testimony or false forensic evidence to convict defendants of murder, rape and other felonies, reports the Washington Post. The forensic experts in these cases were trained by the same elite FBI team whose members gave misleading court testimony about hair matches and later taught the local examiners to follow the same suspect practices, according to interviews and documents. In July, the Justice Department announced a nationwide review of all cases handled by the FBI Laboratory’s hair and fibers unit before 2000 — at least 21,000 cases — to determine whether improper lab reports or testimony might have contributed to wrongful convictions.

But about three dozen FBI agents trained 600 to 1,000 state and local examiners to apply the same standards that have proved problematic. None of the local cases is included in the federal review. As a result, legal experts say, although the federal inquiry is laudable, the number of flawed cases at the state and local levels could be even higher, and those are going uncorrected. The FBI review was prompted by a Washington Post series about errors at the bureau’s renowned crime lab involving microscopic hair comparisons. 

« Article List

Comments

please type in the letters in the image
No Comments yet

TCR at a Glance

Marrying Police Craft to Science

new & notable June 18, 2013

Law enforcement needs to resolve the long-running dispute between supporters of evidence-based policing and practitioners of experiential...

Smile, You’re Under Arrest

June 17, 2013

U.S. cops are increasingly using micro cameras to record their daily activities—and defend themselves, if necessary, against charge...

Violence in Juvenile Justice Facilities

new & notable June 13, 2013

Nearly half of youths in containment experience theft and almost a third are threatened or beaten, according to the Office of Juvenile Ju...

When Love Hurts

June 11, 2013

A few states—such as New York—are expanding orders of civil protection and establishing special courts for teens at risk from...